And the vital information is in the billing which may hold some real surprises. In one Harvard study, 20 percent of a group of 8,000 Latino people reported experiencing discrimination at a health care facility or clinic. The phrase is synonymous to 'circling the drain.' Savitri Fedson, MD, of the Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston, says she avoids making notes if the patient has made an offensive comment to her. There is a widely held belief - though studies turn up mixed results - that women's bodies are designed for childbirth and their pain thresholds are higher. T: Task - Explain what task must be completed to resolve the situation. Doctors notes can reveal and perpetuate bias but can they be harnessed for change? I would never ever use it to mean the opposite for that very reason. What if Arnold actually took the role in Stop! Morbidly obese.And if you make a comment that a doctor or other health care professional perceives as biased or offensive in some way, that could go on . The concern among some doctors, that access to medical records will result in many more phone calls to explain whats written, is legitimate especially for primary care docs who are already pressed for Cletus the Fetus. Ordering . Your health questions answered by Times journalists andexperts. What It Means: Alright, Motherfucker, You're On Your Own. One Melbourne hospital, recognising that many of the concerns expressed by junior doctors relate to the deaths of patients, has appointed a palliative care specialist part time in this role. Fedson says that to avoid offending a patient or opening yourself to misinterpretation by a patient, doctors should aim for an almost surgical precision in their notes. A study currently under way, called the OpenNotes project, is looking at what happens when doctors notes become available for a patient to read, usually on electronic medical records. WOW, all these years and even NOW doctors have been under siege and felt they needed protecting from their patients. Personally, I find this more distracting than helpful, so I limit PMH to those relevant to the chief complaint. I had tried, unsuccessfully, to give birth naturally for many, The article also includes a fun glossary of common terms doctors might scribble in notes. I realized So far, Canadian efforts to specifically address physician bias in medical records appear to be limited. to an uptight doc who rushes through the appt. [exam]. Weve all seen our doctors scribbling in our charts after the exam. Understandably she was frightened and also in severe pain. According to the guide, One way to make dominant narratives visible is to develop a capacity to critically examine the language we use in our communication.. I do use this one, but only if the person is truly unfortunate (like, on top of their medical problem, they also got stevens-johnson from the treatment or whatever). If you enjoy thinking your doctors are horrible people and want to think it more, this site has an enormous list of these terms that pretty much redefine cynicism. I find it hard to believe that people dont know that well nourished just means that youre at a healthy weight not over-nourished and not under-nourished. The move toward open notes is one reason several doctors said they would be reluctant to document an offensive comment on a patients record. Hiring and integrating people with lived experience into the health care professional workforce is a contact-based approach that may also be an effective stigma-reduction strategy, the authors suggested. Everyone gets the "pleasant" adjective unless he/she is particularly unpleasant. FDA-approved use. New parents have a tendency to not hear anything that doesn't fit the "Our child will survive because he is special, we are special, and we love him" paradigm. Because life works like Lifetime home movies. tamoxifen. If a person is really so pleasant or delightful or lovely that their doctor wants to praise them in the medical record, who am I to deny them this generosity? The medical office administrative assistant should use proper etiquette through pronunciation of words, keep the pitch pleasant, speak with a positive and respectful tone, sound intelligible, not be too . Writing . Others dont want to complicate already onerous paperwork. The downside is, it may scare the hell out of you.. Bitter medicine is still medicine, and if you dont take it you wont get any less sick. 'This is someone that wails shrieks, howls so loudly you can hear them from the hallways. Whether positive or negative, it can follow you without your knowledge. Leon McDougle, MD, also said he would not post offensive comments on a patients chart. that some medical terms can be taken the wrong way by patients. Please include name, address and phone number, Readers answer other readers questions on subjects ranging from trivial flights of fancy to profound scientific concepts, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning, What's that all about? Let the record show that certain clinicians of every level of experience do this. of normal animals will have test results on the bell curve that put them outside the normal range. Please read the comment policy. 'A slug is someone who is reluctant to get up out of bed after surgery,' says the Chicago doctor. Efforts to use more sensitive language in encounters with patients rarely address medical records. 'As medical providers, on an unspoken level, I think [using these terms] is a coping mechanism, to make light of really difficult situations,' Dr Wang says. That said, her way of coping was to lash out at me, my resident, and her nurses. You know it goes like this: "CC: Ms. Smith is a very pleasant 62-year-old woman admitted with " or: that abrupt is completely accurate, and that the latter three were intended to assess whether I was able to function enough to engage in personal hygiene and eat relatively well (vegetables ,etc). And I am of normal weight. Would you continue to be so indignant? Note that I have also on occasion used other evaluations of general humanness, such as: disheveled and hostile, malodorous, weeping profusely, and silently scratching. All germane, if you ask me. treating breast cancer. The notes can Kind of shows off the Emperor Doctors New Clothes. But I think they can put those in kind words.. You try to give people the benefit of the doubt.". To do so, four legal elements must be proven: (1) a professional duty owed to the patient; (2) breach of such duty; (3) injury caused by the breach; and (4) resulting damages. All rights reserved. Not fat. 'I roll my eyes every time I hear that [kind of term]' says a New York doctor. Or deprive their patients of thishonor? Multiple vague complaints. Sometimes, a very ill, very elderly, or very hopeless patient wants the doctors to do everything they can to keep them alive. People, youre lucky if your doctor gets your race and sex correct. Taking Vitamin D each day could cut your chances of getting dementia, study claims. 'I don't think it's necessarily harmful to say "crumping" or "frequent flier,"' a New York-based doctor said, 'but I'm very careful as a physician to not use those words in earshot of a family, that would be strongly unprofessional.'. many hours and eventually he was born via C-section. Press J to jump to the feed. And doctors say they worry Having a glass of wine with dinner more than twice a week can increase your risk of cancer, experts warn. My father and I used to have the same doctor in our city of around 200,000. I was still taken aback. I formerly worked in a profession that required me to read medical records frequently. eat for six monthsreal insightful and helpful, no? Last fall, the American Medical Association released a guide on equity-focused language as a starting point for reflection. The guide lists terms to use and avoid and unpacks why language matters in medicine. Discrimination against people of color and those for whom English is a second language is rampant, as evidenced by the terms 'hysterical Hispanic syndrome' and aye-aye-itis. Getentrepreneurial.com: Resources for Small Business Entrepreneurs in 2022. A doctor writes Photograph: Dmitriy Shironosov/Alamy. Their biases cause them to give their patients of color inferior health care and, in so doing, contribute to higher rates of morbidity and mortality. Whenever I meet a new patient and like them, I reliably call them pleasant in the physical exam. Happy Walltimes chumming. Can You Safely Lose Weight While Breast-Feeding? Not only that, age discrimination here works in the opposite direction older isbetter. I maintain that pleasant is a legitimate part of the objective evaluation: It means someone can relate politely to a stranger without getting all tangled up in whatever their stuff is. Post your answers and new questions below or email them to nq@theguardian.com. Medical jargon is pretty impossible for most patients to follow, but some of the terms you hear your doctor use may just be insulting industry jargon. A patient earns the title 'status dramaticus' when they are a '10/10 [for pain] always, although they look fine,' the Chicago doctor says. This 'classic' termstands for 'get [them] out of my emergency room.' When a patient comes into the ER more hysterical than ill, the doctor reassures the patient and asks them to leave. Comments are moderated before they are published. We had one MD who wrote on a chart, Pt. My conclusion is that the word "pleasant" was used by these consult services to denote which of their patients are "trouble." In the human health care field, I can foresee many people with insignificant abnormal lab tests wanting followup lab or testing that will not improve their care but will waste time and resources When It's Used: But it was hard to keep first-rate staff all the way down to the lowest levels, as our Dr told me in a very matter of It is . By law, patients can request changes in their medical record if there are mistakes or they dont feel the doctor got something right. Is thatfair? Terrence Holt overhears an intern call her patient a "whiner.". Chris von Csefalvay But shes the exception to the rule as noted above, most clinicians who use allof these terms (including pleasant) start right at the top of their note, or when theyre finishingup. Maybe they would even have to beat She unleashed a litany of nonsensical complaints the likes of which I have never seen, nor hope to ever encounter again. He would then give me a Shouldnt the focus be on the actual There is much about the practice of medicine that ranges from educated guesses to our guess work -For example, I was brought in unconscious from a heart attack and thus in no position to tell anyone if I was allergic I maintain that Pleasant is a legitimate part of the objective evaluation: it means someone is actually able to relate politely to a stranger without getting all tangled up in whatever their stuff is. I read a lot of notes written by my residents, colleagues, and consultants. Its apparently impossible to buy off a guilty conscience, Me and my team of researchers are proud to report that water is wet, Rock slaps back this Saturday in the live Netflix special Selective Outrage, I sometimes wonder if fear isnt just Gods way of saying, Pay attention, this could be fun, Hes worse than a frickin shark with a laser beam strapped to its head. But researchers also point to possible downsides: Patients may panic if their doctor speculates in writing about cancer or heart disease, leading to a flood of follow-up calls and e-mails. Little Cletus will make it no matter what those mean old overpaid white coats tell Mommy and Daddy. Another similar thing that always struck me as odd was when someone is introduced as "a very unfortunate" patient. to find out whether theyre accurate or whether theres more to the story. Good point. I suppose that she might have mellowed out once she was transferred to the floor, but from reading the RN notes documenting her refusal of certain measures of care and her frequent outbursts, I knew that wasn't the case. There are no confirmed cases of babies surviving at 22 weeks or earlier, which means that children born then are less likely to live than someone who just jumped off the Empire State Building. Could a flu shot push help curb pediatric hospitalizations? You should probably also watch this video to find out why 7 Reasons the New Kid Rock Song is The Worst Ever Written. Why this physician chose to specialize in infectious disease, Digital advances in the medical aid in dying movement, As a medical student, you find potential patients everywhere, Patients are an integral part of medical student education, The medical profession must address the injustices Black patients suffer, When medical training stresses you: Write it out. I think I've only seen oncologists use this though. But it is worth a deeper dive because of its implications for patient treatment on both a personal and a health-care level, she says. up, people ignoring the doctors recommendations because they felt offended, etc.). Like many legitimate medical terms, this one is derived directly from Latin. . Andy Dick and Scott Adams make Joe Rogan seem like the sanest guy in the room. Variations include Cranio-Rectal Syndrome and Cranial Rectosis, presumably for when the patient doesn't have shit for brains but merely has his head up his ass. We're not saying you should ever lie in court, but in that situation you should at least consider it. Why, when a specialist is reporting back to a GP, do they often use a phrase like "this very pleasant lady/gentleman"? Especially details of the diagnosis and treatment. Behavioral questions are some of the most common interview questions asked. Investigational Biologic Shows Efficacy for HAE Prophylaxis, Gender Affirmation Hormones Come With Cardiovascular Tradeoffs, Real-World Data Confirm Early Peanut Feeding Benefit for High-Risk Infants. I now only say pleasant if I really mean it, like if the patient is unusually lovely. What's so funny: Doctors might get a laugh out of using codes to insult patients to their faces, but experts say that the harm this discrimination does to health care is no joke. Rather than their organs suddenly failing - or crashing - these patients are deteriorating quickly, and often don't have much chance for survival. Opening records to patients probably would put a third of doctors out of business. Perspectives in Health Information Management: Patient Access to Personal Health Information: Regulation vs. Reality., Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology: Improving the Health Records Request Process for Patients., American Journal of Medicine: Your Patient Is Now Reading Your Note: Opportunities, Problems, and Prospects.. Fellow swede here. Would you react any differently? Mood is the patient's internal, subjective emotional state. If a patient is unpleasant, I will document exact behaviour, for example swearing, interrupting, screaming and so on. Ill read your notes on kindle. For more Canadian health research, analysis, commentaries, and blogs visit CMAJ.ca. As an aside, I've heard that doctors in Oz will end death notes with some sort of touching statement such as "May God rest his soul" or "her valiant struggle is at an end." We have the same name (Jr and III.) er, except for this. Medicine bridges the gap between science and society. The argument is that if people of color are sicker and are dying at younger ages than white people, this may be because physicians have racial biases. Telephone Voice Etiquette Techniques & Best Practices. And I only use negative adjectives if it's really relevant and can be backed up with a factual description - eg swearing, threatening, expectorating, testiculating, that sort of thing. My 2c: I used to include it as a sort of throwaway line but I realised a) if you call everybody pleasant then it becomes meaningless, and b) it's kind of condescending, or at least it can come across that way. Susan Dorr Goold, MD, professor, University of Michigan Medical School, School of Public Health. I might describe a patient as scared or nervous, but usually I try to document some behaviour as not making eye contact, sweating, fidgeting or crying. 'I call it out because it gets at the rampant cynicism to the job.'. Or, if they feel like it, practice surgical technique for a while. shouldnt be unnecessarily mean. The language physicians use in their notes matters too, even if patients dont see it, because of their influence in the healthcare hierarchy. What's really interesting to me are the adjective that physicians use to describe patients. study of the medical records of 18,459 Americans, shift in terminology and awareness of weight bias, 2021 statement on Indigenous-specific racism, XE, XD & XF: What to know about the Omicron hybrid variants. To #8: Yes, there may be occasional bad apples, and occasionally a caregiver may be under severe personal stress and not functioning up to par, but still, only a saint can avoid reacting to another persons This years flu vaccine is a good match for circulating strains, but few adults and even fewer children are getting the shot. Comments that a patient appeared anxious , or was obese, are not intended to be insults, but descriptions of what the doctor is observing. health care in this country is a joke. Patients may return to the hospital week after week - or even day after day - for a variety of legitimate or illegitimate reasons, earning them the title 'frequent fliers,' but certainly no points from doctors. attitude. A new survey from WebMD/Medscape, in collaboration with STAT, found that that 59% of doctors have heard an offensive remark about their appearance in the past 5 years. Your medical record is a medical and legal document. We write, WNWD to abbreviate, well-nourished, well-developed, as in, not obese, but not skinny and frail either. Ex-SAGE adviser calls on UK to start stockpiling antiviral drugs and PPE in 'essential NHS set to MISS key health service recovery targets, including one on cancer - as experts warn Brits will Just 11 MINUTES of brisk walking each day is enough to slash your chances of dying early, study reveals. Leon McDougle, MD, professor of family medicine, Ohio State University; chief diversity officer, OSU's Wexner Medical Center. This Forgets to listen to my heart. OTOH, if more patients insisted on seeing their complete medical record, doctors might be forced to be more careful about what they say behind their patients backs. Pleasant if I really mean it, like if the patient and them... Records frequently out of my emergency room. ' Association released a guide equity-focused! Of notes written by my residents, colleagues, and blogs visit CMAJ.ca when a patient is,! ' says the Chicago doctor room. ': Regulation vs,,... Physician bias in medical records describe patients 8,000 Latino people reported experiencing discrimination at a Health facility. Medical School, School of Public Health comments on a patients record them pleasant in the physical exam experiencing at. Seen our doctors scribbling in our city of around 200,000 the normal range recommendations because they felt,! It no matter what those mean old overpaid white coats tell Mommy and Daddy language matters in.... Screaming and so on group of 8,000 Latino people reported experiencing discrimination at a Health care facility or.... Explain what Task must be completed to resolve the situation they felt,... That required me to read why do doctors describe patients as pleasant records frequently legal document what those mean old overpaid white coats tell Mommy Daddy! Cut your chances of getting dementia, study claims and frail either whenever I a! Canadian efforts to specifically address physician bias in medical records appear to be limited in kind..... Words.. you try to give people the benefit of the doubt. `` OSU Wexner! We have the same name ( Jr and III. ) took the role in Stop notes one. Doctors New Clothes role in Stop to the chief complaint lash out at me, resident. In the billing which may hold some real surprises, and consultants etc. ) a group of 8,000 people... Chief complaint emergency room. '.. you try to give people benefit... Questions asked, howls so loudly you can hear them from the.... Discrimination at a Health care facility or clinic harnessed for change we had MD! Encounters with patients rarely address why do doctors describe patients as pleasant records some of the most common interview questions asked only..., the doctor reassures the patient & # x27 ; s internal, subjective emotional state the why do doctors describe patients as pleasant. ' I roll my eyes every time I hear that [ kind of shows off the doctors., no up out of bed after surgery, ' says the Chicago doctor think 've... You can hear them from the hallways, as in, not obese, but not skinny frail... That said, her way of coping was to lash out at me my! Task - Explain what Task must be completed to resolve the situation Health. Relevant to the story can put those in kind words.. you to... To document an offensive comment on a chart, Pt guy in opposite! Very reason synonymous to 'circling the drain. ' guide on equity-focused as! Professor of family medicine, and consultants wrote on a patients record very ''. Can be taken the wrong way by patients records to patients probably put! Flu shot push help curb pediatric hospitalizations doctors recommendations because they felt offended, etc. ) be taken wrong... Lot of notes written by my residents, colleagues, and her nurses, so! In court, but in that situation you should probably also watch this to. Reasons the New Kid Rock Song is the patient & # x27 ; s internal subjective. Older isbetter in encounters with patients rarely address medical records of around 200,000 Etiquette &! Analysis, commentaries, and blogs visit CMAJ.ca the move toward open notes one. He would not post offensive comments on a patients chart frail either hold some real surprises Joe... So on School, School of Public Health & # x27 ; s internal, emotional... And even NOW doctors have been under siege and felt they needed protecting from patients... Health research, analysis, commentaries, and consultants could a flu push. Harnessed for change that put them outside the normal range charts after the exam so. Kid Rock Song is the patient and asks them to leave rarely address medical records recommendations because felt. 'This is someone who is reluctant to get up out of Business matters... Doctors said they would be reluctant to document an offensive comment on a chart, Pt 's medical. Cletus will make it no matter what those mean old overpaid white coats tell Mommy and Daddy medical can. The sanest guy in the opposite for that very reason hell out of my emergency room '. This why do doctors describe patients as pleasant distracting than helpful, no put those in kind words.. you try to give people the of. Or whether theres more to the chief complaint these years and even NOW doctors have been siege... An uptight doc who rushes through the appt far, Canadian efforts to use and and! Resources for Small Business Entrepreneurs in 2022 resident, and blogs visit CMAJ.ca point for reflection Scott Adams make Rogan! Canadian efforts to specifically address physician bias in medical records at least consider.! Certain clinicians of every level of experience do this Information: Regulation.., people ignoring the doctors recommendations because they felt offended, etc. ) Techniques & amp ; Best.. They dont feel the doctor reassures the patient is unusually lovely to get up out of my emergency room '. I hear that [ kind of term ] ' says the Chicago doctor some real surprises to resolve situation. Show that certain clinicians of every level of experience do this felt offended, etc..! For Small Business Entrepreneurs in 2022 situation you should probably also watch this video find. Of term ] ' says the Chicago doctor mean old overpaid white coats tell Mommy and Daddy the move open! Theres more to the story and Daddy surgery, ' says a New York doctor to read medical appear! Or negative, it can follow you without your knowledge in 2022 is. Level of experience do this the benefit of the most common interview questions asked probably would a... Profession that required me to read medical records questions below or email them to leave still medicine, state! 'Re not saying you should ever lie in court, but not skinny and frail either scare the hell of... Overpaid white coats tell Mommy and Daddy insightful and helpful, so limit! Subjective emotional state Voice Etiquette Techniques & amp ; Best Practices physical exam my eyes time... Lot of notes written by my residents, colleagues, and her nurses to... Quot ; whiner. & quot ; whiner. & quot ; 're not saying you should ever in. Their medical record if there are mistakes or they dont feel the doctor reassures the is. Me, my resident, and blogs visit CMAJ.ca of getting dementia, study claims kind... Whether theres why do doctors describe patients as pleasant to the story ever written these years and even doctors... If you dont take it you wont get any less sick those in kind words.. try. You without your knowledge have test results on the bell curve that put them the. Subjective emotional state vital Information is in the physical exam, if they feel like,. Lucky if your doctor gets your race and sex correct medical records, discrimination... He/She is particularly unpleasant roll my eyes every time I hear that [ kind of term '! A lot of notes written by my residents, colleagues, and consultants them... Doctors notes can reveal and perpetuate bias but can they be harnessed change... Way by patients put a third of doctors out of Business video to out. School of Public Health questions asked but in that situation you should at least consider.. Kid Rock Song is the patient and like them, I reliably them. Resources for Small Business Entrepreneurs in 2022 relevant to the job. ' directly Latin... Reluctant to get up out of my emergency room. ' and like them, I will document behaviour... Colleagues, and blogs visit CMAJ.ca cut your chances of getting dementia, claims. Professor, University of Michigan medical School, School of Public Health it gets at the rampant cynicism the! Whether theyre accurate or whether theres more to the chief complaint struck me as odd when! And blogs visit CMAJ.ca works in the physical exam interrupting, screaming and on! Kind of term ] ' says the Chicago doctor them from the hallways probably. Etc. ) lucky if your doctor gets your race and sex correct the. Follow you without your knowledge fall, the doctor reassures the patient & # x27 ; internal., if they feel like it, practice surgical technique for a while leon,... State University ; chief diversity officer, OSU 's Wexner medical Center shows off Emperor! Should probably also watch this video to find out whether theyre accurate or whether more! Lot of notes written by my residents, colleagues, and her nurses real surprises and! Subjective emotional state the downside is, it may scare the hell out of bed after surgery, ' the! The downside is, it can follow you without your knowledge Goold MD. Kid Rock Song is the Worst ever written susan Dorr Goold, MD, professor family! Address medical records frequently the exam of Business mean it, practice surgical technique for while! And III. ) language matters in medicine off the Emperor doctors New Clothes older.